The 2023 Ballon d’Or debate has ignited passionate discussions worldwide, with football enthusiasts grappling over whether Lionel Messi deserved the prestigious award. The crux of the argument in favor of Messi revolves around his monumental achievement: leading Argentina to victory in the 2022 World Cup.
Messi's World Cup Odyssey
The World Cup, often considered the pinnacle of football, holds an unparalleled significance in a player’s career. It’s a stage where dreams are realized, legacies are cemented, and the pressure is unlike any other tournament. Messi, having experienced the heartache of losing a previous final, entered the 2022 World Cup with a profound sense of determination and the weight of expectations on his shoulders.
The narrative took an unexpected turn as Argentina faced an early setback, losing their opening game in the tournament. The stakes became higher, the pressure more intense, but Messi, the captain, exhibited unparalleled leadership. His journey throughout the World Cup was not just about winning; it was a testament to resilience, grit, and an insatiable desire for success.
A Record-Breaking Display of Brilliance
Messi’s scoring spree in every round of the competition showcased not only his brilliance but also his ability to rise to the occasion when it mattered most. He not only secured the Golden Ball for himself but also the Silver Boots, a testament to his prolific goal-scoring form. The sheer dominance exhibited by Messi was further highlighted by breaking several records during the tournament. Most man-of-the-match awards in World Cup history, the first player to win two World Cup Golden Balls, and the first player in history to score in every round of a World Cup tournament — these records etch Messi’s name in the annals of football history.
Ronaldo Nazario's 2002 Ballon d'Or Triumph as a Precedent
Drawing a parallel to historical precedence, the argument in favor of Messi gains additional weight when considering Ronaldo Nazario’s 2002 Ballon d’Or win. Despite playing 836 minutes of club football in the preceding season, Ronaldo’s stellar World Cup performance secured him the coveted individual award. This comparison underscores the undeniable influence of a successful World Cup campaign on the Ballon d’Or race.
Beyond Champions League Exit
Transitioning to Messi’s club-level performances with Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) in the 2022-23 season, critics might point to the early exit from the Champions League as a dent in his candidacy. However, a closer examination reveals a different story. Messi, far from being a mere passenger, contributed significantly to PSG’s campaign. With eight goal contributions in seven Champions League games and 32 goal contributions in 32 league appearances, Messi’s impact was substantial. Moreover, finishing as the player with the most assists in Ligue 1 and earning a spot in the Ligue 1 Team of the Season underscored his influence in France.
- All
- Retro Football Shirts
- International
- Leagues
- Other Clubs
- Stars Collection
- Back
- AC Milan
- Fiorentina
- Inter Milan
- Juventus
- Lazio
- Napoli
- Roma
- Sampdoria
- Parma
- Back
- Argentina
- Brazil
- Belgium
- Croatia
- Chile
- Denmark
- England
- France
- Germany
- Netherland
- Italy
- Ireland
- Mexico
- Nigeria
- Spain
- Sweden
- Scotland
- Wales
- Portugal
- Colombia
- Czech
- Back
- Arsenal
- Aston Villa
- Chelsea
- Everton
- Leeds United
- Liverpool
- Manchester City
- Manchester United
- Nottingham Forest
- Newcastle
- Tottenham
- West Ham United
- Back
- Athletic Bilbao
- Atletico Madrid
- Barcelona
- Real Betis
- Real Madrid
- Valencia
- Back
- Atletico Mineiro
- BOCA JUNIORS
- Club America
- Flamengo
- Gremio
- PUMAS UNAM
- RIVER PLATE
- SPORTING LISBON
- VENEZIA
- Back
- Bayern Munich
- Dortmund
- Back
- Premiership
- La Liga
- SERIE A
- BUNDESLIGA
- SPFL
- Eredivisie
- Ligue 1
- Arsenal
- Aston Villa
- Chelsea
- Everton
- Leeds United
- Liverpool
- Manchester City
- Manchester United
- Nottingham Forest
- Newcastle
- Tottenham
- West Ham United
- Athletic Bilbao
- Atletico Madrid
- Barcelona
- Real Betis
- Real Madrid
- Valencia
- AC Milan
- Fiorentina
- Inter Milan
- Juventus
- Lazio
- Napoli
- Roma
- Sampdoria
- Parma
- Bayern Munich
- Dortmund
- Celtic
- Rangers
- Ajax
- FEYENOORD
- PSV EINDHOVEN
- LYON
- Marseille
- PSG
- Back
- Celtic
- Rangers
- Back
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Karim Benzema
- Mohamed Salah
- Harry Kane
- Kylian Mbappe
- Lionel Messi
- David Beckham
- Ronaldinho
- Maradona
- Pele
- Back
- Ajax
- FEYENOORD
- PSV EINDHOVEN
- Back
- LYON
- Marseille
- PSG
Erling Haaland's Club Brilliance
Acknowledging Erling Haaland’s exceptional season with Manchester City, where he achieved a European treble, won the Premier League Golden Boot, and received multiple individual awards, it’s evident that Haaland had a stellar club season. His goal-scoring prowess and record-breaking feats set a benchmark for excellence. However, the discussion takes an intriguing turn when the World Cup’s weight in the Ballon d’Or race is brought into focus.
The World Cup Void
Haaland’s absence from the 2022 World Cup, a consequence of Norway’s inability to secure qualification, emerges as a crucial factor. In a year when the spectacle of the World Cup enraptures the global football community, it becomes challenging to justify awarding the Ballon d’Or to a player absent from the pinnacle of international competition. It raises questions about the completeness of a player’s claim to the title when one crucial element, the World Cup, is missing from the equation.
In essence, the debate boils down to a qualitative assessment. Haaland’s club-level achievements in the 2022-23 season are undoubtedly exceptional, arguably warranting a Ballon d’Or in any other year. However, when pitted against Messi’s dual triumphs — a stellar club performance and the crowning glory of leading Argentina to World Cup victory — the scales tip decisively in Messi’s favor.
Dismissing Misconceptions Surrounding Messi's Club Form
It’s crucial to dispel any notion that Messi’s club performances were lackluster due to the Champions League exit. Statistical analysis reveals that Messi ranked in the top five for goal contributions and chances created from open play in Europe’s top five leagues during the 2022-23 season. Additionally, he secured top positions for significant cases made and completed dribbles, showcasing his all-encompassing influence on the pitch.
Messi's Unrivaled Claim to the 2023 Ballon d'Or
In conclusion, Lionel Messi’s claim to the 2023 Ballon d’Or is grounded in the holistic nature of his achievements. His World Cup triumph, coupled with noteworthy club performances, creates a narrative of unparalleled success in a single season. While Erling Haaland’s club exploits are undeniably outstanding, the absence of a World Cup campaign places Messi in a category of his own in the 2023 Ballon d’Or discussion. The combination of individual brilliance, leadership, and a historic World Cup victory positions Messi as the deserving recipient of football’s most coveted individual accolade.
BUY MESSI FOOTBALL SHIRTS
- All
- Retro Football Shirts
- International
- Leagues
- Other Clubs
- Stars Collection
- Back
- AC Milan
- Fiorentina
- Inter Milan
- Juventus
- Lazio
- Napoli
- Roma
- Sampdoria
- Parma
- Back
- Argentina
- Brazil
- Belgium
- Croatia
- Chile
- Denmark
- England
- France
- Germany
- Netherland
- Italy
- Ireland
- Mexico
- Nigeria
- Spain
- Sweden
- Scotland
- Wales
- Portugal
- Colombia
- Czech
- Back
- Arsenal
- Aston Villa
- Chelsea
- Everton
- Leeds United
- Liverpool
- Manchester City
- Manchester United
- Nottingham Forest
- Newcastle
- Tottenham
- West Ham United
- Back
- Athletic Bilbao
- Atletico Madrid
- Barcelona
- Real Betis
- Real Madrid
- Valencia
- Back
- Atletico Mineiro
- BOCA JUNIORS
- Club America
- Flamengo
- Gremio
- PUMAS UNAM
- RIVER PLATE
- SPORTING LISBON
- VENEZIA
- Back
- Bayern Munich
- Dortmund
- Back
- Premiership
- La Liga
- SERIE A
- BUNDESLIGA
- SPFL
- Eredivisie
- Ligue 1
- Arsenal
- Aston Villa
- Chelsea
- Everton
- Leeds United
- Liverpool
- Manchester City
- Manchester United
- Nottingham Forest
- Newcastle
- Tottenham
- West Ham United
- Athletic Bilbao
- Atletico Madrid
- Barcelona
- Real Betis
- Real Madrid
- Valencia
- AC Milan
- Fiorentina
- Inter Milan
- Juventus
- Lazio
- Napoli
- Roma
- Sampdoria
- Parma
- Bayern Munich
- Dortmund
- Celtic
- Rangers
- Ajax
- FEYENOORD
- PSV EINDHOVEN
- LYON
- Marseille
- PSG
- Back
- Celtic
- Rangers
- Back
- Cristiano Ronaldo
- Karim Benzema
- Mohamed Salah
- Harry Kane
- Kylian Mbappe
- Lionel Messi
- David Beckham
- Ronaldinho
- Maradona
- Pele
- Back
- Ajax
- FEYENOORD
- PSV EINDHOVEN
- Back
- LYON
- Marseille
- PSG
