Manchester City's Impact: The Ruined Careers Of 7 Players

Manchester City, a club esteemed globally, has come under scrutiny for purportedly obstructing the careers of several players. This article scrutinises the narratives of seven individuals whose professional trajectories suffered setbacks upon their association with or departure from the club.

Kalvin Phillips:

Kalvin Phillips, formerly a rising star at Leeds United, faced a career setback at Manchester City. Despite a promising initiation, his trajectory took a downturn due to Pep Guardiola’s lack of faith. This resulted in Phillips losing his coveted spot in the England national team, a stark consequence of his move to City in 2022. The midfielder, once sought after by top clubs, found himself on the sidelines under Guardiola’s management. The regrettable outcome not only impacted Phillips’ national team prospects but also raised questions about the compatibility of his playing style with Guardiola’s system. Amidst the challenges, Phillips’ journey also highlights the importance of maintaining individuality, both on and off the pitch, as he navigates through adversity, perhaps finding solace in the unique identity expressed through the best retro jerseys that add a touch of nostalgia to his footballing narrative.

Joe Hart:

Joe Hart, a former England and Manchester City goalkeeper, experienced a significant blow to his illustrious career under the management of Pep Guardiola. The once-esteemed goalkeeper faced a series of loan moves as a consequence, marking a stark decline from his status as a top-tier goalkeeper to a less prominent role. Guardiola’s arrival in 2016 marked a turning point, as he deemed Hart surplus to requirements, emphasizing the need for improvement in his playing style, particularly with his feet. The ensuing loan spells at Torino and West Ham further signaled a downward trajectory. Ultimately, Hart’s departure from City in 2018 marked the end of an era, and his subsequent moves to Burnley, Spurs, and Celtic underscored the challenges he encountered in reclaiming his former status on the football stage.

All
Retro Football Shirts
International
Leagues
Other Clubs
Stars Collection

Back
AC Milan
Fiorentina
Inter Milan
Juventus
Lazio
Napoli
Roma
Sampdoria
Parma

Back
Argentina
Brazil
Belgium
Croatia
Chile
Denmark
England
France
Germany
Netherland
Italy
Ireland
Mexico
Nigeria
Spain
Sweden
Scotland
Wales
Portugal
Colombia
Czech

Back
Arsenal
Aston Villa
Chelsea
Everton
Leeds United
Liverpool
Manchester City
Manchester United
Nottingham Forest
Newcastle
Tottenham
West Ham United

Back
Athletic Bilbao
Atletico Madrid
Barcelona
Real Betis
Real Madrid
Valencia

Back
Atletico Mineiro
BOCA JUNIORS
Club America
Flamengo
Gremio
PUMAS UNAM
RIVER PLATE
SPORTING LISBON
VENEZIA

Back
Bayern Munich
Dortmund

Back
Premiership
La Liga
SERIE A
BUNDESLIGA
SPFL
Eredivisie
Ligue 1
Arsenal
Aston Villa
Chelsea
Everton
Leeds United
Liverpool
Manchester City
Manchester United
Nottingham Forest
Newcastle
Tottenham
West Ham United
Athletic Bilbao
Atletico Madrid
Barcelona
Real Betis
Real Madrid
Valencia
AC Milan
Fiorentina
Inter Milan
Juventus
Lazio
Napoli
Roma
Sampdoria
Parma
Bayern Munich
Dortmund
Celtic
Rangers
Ajax
FEYENOORD
PSV EINDHOVEN
LYON
Marseille
PSG

Back
Celtic
Rangers

Back
Cristiano Ronaldo
Karim Benzema
Mohamed Salah
Harry Kane
Kylian Mbappe
Lionel Messi
David Beckham
Ronaldinho
Maradona
Pele

Back
Ajax
FEYENOORD
PSV EINDHOVEN

Back
LYON
Marseille
PSG

Boca Juniors 1981 Long Sleeve Home Retro Football Shirt

View Products

Napoli 1988-1989 Home Retro Football Shirt

View Products

Argentina 1978 World Cup Retro Home Soccer Jersey

View Products

Claudio Bravo:

Claudio Bravo, previously successful with Barcelona and Chile, faced adversity at Manchester City. Despite his prior accomplishments, he encountered challenges that hindered his performance. The crucial blow came as he lost his starting position to Ederson, City’s subsequent goalkeeper. Unfortunately, Bravo struggled to reclaim his former glory and found himself on the fringes of the squad. His legacy at City contrasts sharply with the triumphs he enjoyed with Barcelona and the Chilean national team. Bravo’s journey at City raises questions about the adaptability of players transitioning between leagues and the intense competition within top-tier clubs. His inability to regain prominence underscores the unforgiving nature of football and the impact it can have on a player’s legacy.

Yaya Toure:

Yaya Toure, a revered City legend, encountered a disheartening farewell marked by a fallout with Pep Guardiola. Despite being a pivotal figure in Manchester City’s success, the Ivorian found himself subjected to poor treatment. The discord between Toure and Guardiola led to an unceremonious departure, leaving fans and pundits questioning the club’s handling of its iconic players. Toure’s significant contributions to City, particularly during the 2013-14 season, where he scored 20 goals from the midfield, added to the perplexity surrounding his less-than-dignified exit. The incident serves as a poignant example of the complexities involved in managing footballing legends and the potential pitfalls when relationships between players and managers sour.

Also Read: 08 Footballers Who Left Their Club In Disgrace

Emmanuel Adebayor:

Emmanuel Adebayor’s 2009 move to City held promise for a bright future, but the club’s subsequent decisions, notably the signing of Edin Dzeko, resulted in his premature departure. The Togolese striker, initially a high-flier at Arsenal, saw his career trajectory take a downward turn. Forced to join Real Madrid on loan in 2011, Adebayor’s subsequent moves included stints at Spurs, Crystal Palace, and various clubs globally. City’s choices and the influx of new talents disrupted Adebayor’s anticipated ascent, highlighting the unpredictability and challenges players may face in navigating the dynamic landscape of top-tier football.

Samir Nasri:

Samir Nasri’s promising start at City was marred by fan criticism and injury setbacks. Despite early successes, the Frenchman’s career took a nosedive, exacerbated by a doping scandal in Turkey. The combination of on-field challenges and off-field controversies accentuated Nasri’s struggles. Criticized by fans for perceived inconsistencies, Nasri’s departure from Manchester City in 2016 did not mark a positive turning point. His subsequent move to Sevilla on loan and later to Antalyaspor in Turkey further underscored the challenges he faced. Nasri’s journey serves as a poignant reminder of the complexities and obstacles players may encounter during their careers, especially in the high-pressure environment of top football clubs.

Benjamin Mendy:

Benjamin Mendy’s off-field legal battles aligned with alleged negligence from City, with the club reportedly withholding his wages for two years. The Frenchman’s predicament unveils a grim picture of a player grappling with both legal and financial hardships. While facing legal allegations, Mendy continued to be a City player until 2023 when his contract expired, during which the club purportedly failed to remit his due payments since September 2021. The situation sheds light on the challenges Mendy confronted, dealing with not only legal complexities but also financial uncertainties, highlighting the intersection of personal struggles and professional obligations in the demanding world of professional football.

Conclusion:

Manchester City’s impact on these players raises questions about the club’s management and its treatment of key figures. The stories of Phillips, Hart, Bravo, Toure, Adebayor, Nasri, and Mendy collectively depict a pattern of career setbacks associated with their time at or departure from the club.